March 11, 2024

CAPintel

Annual Incentive Plans – Payouts and Performance Alignment

Download

DOWNLOAD A PDF OF THIS REPORT pdf(0.4MB)

Contact

Melissa Burek
Founding Partner [email protected] 212-921-9354
Michael Bonner
Principal [email protected] 646-486-9744
Thomas Brown
Analyst [email protected] 646-568-1159
Grace Tan
Analyst [email protected] 646-568-1162

Share

CAP analyzed annual incentive plan payouts over the past ten years of 120 large U.S. public companies, with a median revenue of $43B. We selected these companies to span ten major industries and provide a broad representation of market practice. This study is a continuation of studies that we conducted in 2017 and 2020.

Annual incentive plans are an essential tool for companies to incent and reward executives for achieving short-term financial and strategic goals. The goal-setting process has always challenged management teams and committees to achieve a balance between rigor and attainability to motivate executives.

In recent years, economic volatility has placed even more pressure on committees to set appropriate goals. This research is intended to be a guide and a reference point to help evaluate whether goal-setting has led to the right outcomes.

Highlights

1

Based on our analysis of actual incentive payouts over the past ten years, the degree of difficulty, or “stretch”, embedded in annual performance goals translates to:

  • A 95 percent chance of achieving at least Threshold performance
  • A 70 percent chance of achieving at least Target performance
  • A 5 percent chance of achieving Maximum performance

2

This pattern reinforces the importance of performance metric selection and performance goal setting, given that companies are spending annual incentive monies equal to at least the amount of their overall target pool 70 percent of the time.

3

Annual incentive payout distributions in 2020-2021 are outliers, despite a significant portion of companies making adjustments to their bonus payouts in 2020-2021, given the impact of the pandemic on businesses.

Summary of Findings

Plan Design

For the purposes of this study, we categorized annual incentive plans as either goal attainment or discretionary. Companies with goal attainment plans set threshold, target, and maximum performance goals and corresponding payout opportunities for the performance period. Companies with discretionary plans determine payouts at year-end based on a retrospective review of performance results with no predefined relationship between goals and payouts.

Our study focuses on the 89 percent of companies in the sample with goal attainment plans.

Industry

Sample Size

Annual Incentive Plan Type

Goal Attainment

Discretionary

Automotive

n= 11

100%

0%

Consumer Goods

n= 14

100%

0%

Financial Services

n= 15

40%

60%

Health Care

n= 11

100%

0%

Insurance

n= 12

83%

17%

Manufacturing

n= 10

90%

10%

Oil and Gas

n= 11

91%

9%

Pharmaceutical

n= 12

100%

0%

Retail

n= 11

100%

0%

Technology

n= 12

100%

0%

Total

89%

11%

Performance Metrics

Nearly three-quarters of the companies in our study use three or more metrics to determine bonus funding, an increase compared to the findings of our 2020 report.

9%8%9%30%11%17%7%9%9%36%17%27%20%33%14%9%8%17%45%58%36%20%22%50%36%27%40%25%36%9%17%27%30%33%33%43%55%60%67%38%RetailTechnologyHealth CareInsuranceManufacturingFinancial ServicesConsumer GoodsAutomotiveOil and GasPharmaceuticalAll CompaniesNumber of Metrics Used in Goal Attainment Plans: 20231 Metric2 Metrics3 Metrics4+ Metrics

The most prevalent financial metrics used in annual incentive plans were Revenue, EPS, and Operating Income (including EBIT, EBITDA, and Pre-tax Income).

57 percent of companies in our current study use strategic or nonfinancial goals, an increase from 38 percent in 2020. These metrics incentivize behaviors that contribute to long-term success but may not be captured by short-term financial performance results. Specific strategic or nonfinancial metrics vary by industry and company – for example, pharmaceutical companies often use pipeline metrics and oil and gas companies often use safety and environmental metrics.

60 percent of the companies include Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) goals as part of their annual incentive award determination. ESG metrics are typically evaluated on a qualitative basis, and less commonly on a quantitative basis.

Performance and Pay Scales

Compensation committees annually approve threshold, target, and maximum performance goals and corresponding payout opportunities for each metric in the incentive plan. Target performance goals are most often set in line with the company’s internal business plan. Executives most often earn 50 percent of their target bonus opportunity for achieving threshold performance and 200 percent for achieving maximum performance. Only two companies in the study provide an award opportunity over 200 percent of target for achieving maximum performance goals, a decrease compared to our 2020 report.

Annual Incentive Plan Payouts Relative to Goals

All Companies

Based on CAP’s analysis over the 10-year period, the degree of “stretch” embedded in annual performance goals translates to approximately:

  • A 95 percent chance of achieving at least Threshold performance
  • A 70 percent chance of achieving at least Target performance
  • A 5 percent chance of achieving Maximum performance
4%2%24%10%52%7%0%10%20%30%40%50%60%No PayoutThresholdThreshold - TargetTargetTarget - MaxMax10-Year Average Payout Distribution Total Sample: 2013-2022

This shows that participants are achieving threshold performance and earning some payout 95 percent of the time and receiving maximum payouts 5 percent of the time by achieving superior results. These findings reinforce the importance of performance goal settings, as companies are spending annual incentive monies equal to at least the amount of their overall target pool about 70% of the time.

99%76%12%94%77%13%93%63%6%95%60%5%96%73%8%98%74%10%96%69%2%92%55%10%100%89%11%97%65%6%0%10%20%30%40%50%60%70%80%90%100%At least ThresholdAt least TargetMaxAt least ThresholdAt least TargetMaxAt least ThresholdAt least TargetMaxAt least ThresholdAt least TargetMaxAt least ThresholdAt least TargetMaxAt least ThresholdAt least TargetMaxAt least ThresholdAt least TargetMaxAt least ThresholdAt least TargetMaxAt least ThresholdAt least TargetMaxAt least ThresholdAt least TargetMax2013201420152016201720182019202020212022Payout Distribution by Year Total Sample: 2013-2022

In most of the years reviewed in our study, between 60 percent and 80 percent of companies paid bonuses at target or above. There were two exceptions: 2020, when only 55 percent of companies paid bonuses at target or above, and 2021, when 89 percent of companies paid bonuses at target or above. In 2020, bonuses were generally down due to the unanticipated impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on financial results, while in 2021 bonuses increased due to a faster than expected rebound for most companies. In 2022, we saw a return to more typical payout distributions with 65 percent of companies paying bonuses at target or above.

Impact of COVID-19 and Adjustments Made in 2020-2021

Given the unique economic environment, companies made more adjustments to annual incentive payouts in 2020 and 2021 than in prior years.

27%13%0%5%10%15%20%25%30%COVID / Discretionary2020COVID / Discretionary2021Prevalence of COVID / Discretionary Adjustments (n=120)

In 2020, 27 percent of companies made adjustments to annual incentive payouts. Approximately half of the companies adjusted bonus payouts upward to acknowledge that executives had limited control over the pandemic’s impact on financial results and to recognize efforts in navigating through the challenging environment. The other half of companies adjusted annual incentive payouts downward to realize the unplanned benefit that some companies realized as a result of the pandemic.

In 2021, 13 percent of companies made downward adjustments to annual incentive payouts to recognize that the results exceeded goals because of a quicker-than-expected financial rebound.

-7%-25%0%-18%34%-6%-30%-20%-10%0%10%20%30%40%2020 (n=32)2021 (n=15)Change in Annual Incentive Payouts Due to COVID/Discretionary Adjustments25th Percentile50th Percentile75th Percentile

The trends seen in the 2020-2021 period reflect a dynamic response to the rapidly changing economic
landscape and emphasize the importance of adaptability for companies when navigating unprecedented times.

By Industry

Payout distributions differ by industry based on a variety of factors, including metric selection, goal setting, and economic influences. Average payouts for each industry are distributed as indicated in the following chart:

0%20%40%60%80%100%PharmaceuticalInsuranceOil and GasHealth CareFinancialServicesManufacturingConsumerGoodsRetailAutomotiveTechnologyTotal Sample10-Year Average Payout Distribution by Industry: 2013-2022No PayoutThresholdThreshold - TargetTargetTarget - MaxMax

Pay Relative to Performance

CAP reviewed the relationship between annual incentive payouts and annual company performance over the ten-year period with respect to growth in the three most common annual incentive plan metrics: Revenue, EPS, and Operating Income. Payouts were fairly aligned with all three metrics over the 2013-2022 period, indicating that companies are rewarding for both growth and operating efficiency. Aligning bonus payouts with profitability also helps ensure that outcomes consider a company’s ability to pay bonuses.

The chart below depicts the relationship between median Revenue, EPS, and Operating Income Growth and the prevalence of above-target annual bonus payouts among the sample.

-20%-15%-10%-5%0%5%10%15%20%0%20%40%60%80%100%2013201420152016201720182019202020212022% Change in GrowthPayouts at or above Target (n=120)10-Year Financial Results vs. AIP Payouts: 2013-2022Target and Above PayoutsRevenue GrowthEPS GrowthOperating Income Growth

Conclusion

Our research indicates that over the last ten years companies set performance goals that translated to:

  • A 95 percent chance of achieving at least Threshold performance
  • A 70 percent chance of achieving at least Target performance
  • A 5 percent chance of achieving Maximum performance

While payouts in select years may diverge slightly from others, given economic, industry, or company factors, this overall 10-year lookback provides a pattern and guidelines that companies can use to assess their actual payouts and established goals over the longer-term.

Looking Ahead

The macroeconomic environment remains uncertain, given factors such as the rising interest rate environment, continuing high inflation, a tight labor market, stock price volatility in certain sectors, and supply chain uncertainty.

Companies can use design strategies to help reduce volatility in their plan payouts, including setting wider ranges around target to recognize the challenges of setting performance goals in an uncertain environment, using non-financial goals to tie annual incentive payouts to other markers of company progress, and adding relative measures, which will allow for relevant comparisons even if the overall market is affected by macroeconomic challenges.

Methodology

The 120 companies in our study had a revenue size ranging from $20 billion at the 25th percentile to $88 billion at the 75th percentile. Median revenue was $43 billion.

CAP reviewed actual annual incentive payouts earned for performance over the ten-year period from 2013-2022 to determine the distribution of incentive payments and the frequency with which executives typically achieve target payouts. In this analysis, CAP categorized actual bonus payments (as a percentage of target) into one of six categories based on the following payout ranges:

Payout Category

Payout Range

Max

5% below Max to Max

Target – Max

5% above Target to 5% below Max

Target

+/- 5% of Target

Threshold – Target

5% above Threshold to 5% below Target

Threshold

Up to 5% above Threshold

No Payout

0%